An analysis of different theories on battered women

There are a number of concerns that suggest the need for a reformulation of this model. Although current understanding suggests that violent behavior is not caused by any single factor, much of the research has focused on single causes.

Please use proper attribution. For example, Lang et al. Research on the causes of violence against women has consisted of two lines of inquiry: Walker asserts that, in the domestic abuse ambit, sporadic brutality, perceptions of powerlessness, lack of financial resources and the superior strength of the batterer all combine to instill a feeling of helplessness in the victim.

Generally, professionals help the victim escape by using assertiveness training, modeling and recommending use of the court system. A wide variety of psychiatric and personality disorders have also been diagnosed among sexual offenders, most Page 57 Share Cite Suggested Citation: An expert witnesses' attempt to refocus attention away from pathology after having invoked the concept "battered woman syndrome" can be confusing and appears contradictory.

A simple, yet effective, behavioral strategy consists of two stages.

Battered Women’s Syndrome: Origins, Theory, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder

More recently, battered woman syndrome has been defined as post-traumatic stress disorder PTSD Walker,a psychological condition that results from exposure to severe trauma. Reduced impulse control and personality changes following head injury may lead to an increased risk of battering Detre et al.

Because the indi- vidual was their primary target of analysis and intervention, these authors were the most consistent in the theory they expounded and the level of intervention they proposed.

Social Work Theories and Practice with Battered Women: A Conflict-of-Values Analysis

The second element posits that a lack of options, know-how and finances creates anxiety in the victim over leaving her batterer. Over the years, empirical data has emerged that casts doubt on Dr.

Conflicts regarding moralism center on the degree to which wife abuse should be permitted or controlled. This type of treatment may consist of psychodynamic psychotherapy, behavioral therapy, pharmacotherapy and group therapy. A simple, yet effective, behavioral strategy consists of two stages.

However, with the advent of the theory of post traumatic stress disorder, experts now attribute the etiology of emotional trauma to an external stressor, not a weakness in the psyche of the individual.

The most successful treatments are those that they administer immediately after the traumatic event. In other words, batterers condition women into believing that they are powerless to escape by subjecting them to a continuing pattern of uncontrollable violence and abuse.

Inthe American Psychiatric Association added the post traumatic stress disorder classification to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders III, a manual used by mental health professionals to diagnose mental illness.

Alternatively, if the term is used more broadly to refer to a range of psychological reactions to battering, as it often is in actual testimony by experts, then its diagnostic utility is lost since there is no clearly defined criteria for inclusion.

A release of the tensions built during phase one characterizes the active battering phase, which usually last for a period of two to twenty-four hours. This perspective is compatible with the dominant value that treats famil- ial behaviors as permissible as long as they do not affect persons outside the family.

Conclusion An extensive scientific and professional literature concerning traumatic experiences, including domestic violence and victims' reactions to it, provides a solid foundation for expert testimony in cases involving battered women.

Because the body of literature is so large, this article will focus only on articles that were published in social work journals from to No longer were battered women masochistic; they were trapped. However, there is no basis to suggest that PTSD has exclusive or even greater relevance, for either legal or clinical issues, than do other types of psychological reactions to battering.

Additionally, stimuli that the individual associates with the traumatic event can evoke mental images, emotional responses and psychological reactions associated with the trauma. Finally, the fourth element concludes that the failure of help sources, not learned helplessness, accounts for why many battered women remain with their abusers.

The husbands complained that their wives belittled, nagged, bossed, and criticized them and the wives objected strenuously to their husbands leaving them alone, not helping them at home, and not telling them everything. Reynolds and Siegle, For example, the battered women may avoid her abuser all together and seek help from the court system.

Given the prevalence of domestic abuse in our society, it is important to realize that the battered woman does not like abuse or is responsible for her victimization. In the fourteen articles with a sociological perspective, however, the transformation was not as great.

Analyzing social values can be another way of understanding the adoption of new social policies and new practice strategies.

Looking for other ways to read this?

Typically, the woman showers her abuser with kindness or attempts to avoid him. During the tension building phase, the victim is subjected to verbal abuse and minor battering incidents, such as slaps, pinches and psychological abuse.

The Evolution of Domestic Violence Theory and Law Reform Efforts in the United States published on domestic violence and, therefore, it was their interpretation and analysis of battered women's lives which informed law reform efforts.

theories about domestic violence, such as family systems, which would call for. battered women as a group. (3) Institutional Advocacy Activities: a.

educating systems about the impact of practices on battered women and their children: and b. encouraging systems to change their practices. C. Most advocates were external to the system, working for shelters or battered women's programs.

Battered Women's Syndrome, Free Study Guides and book notes including comprehensive chapter analysis, complete summary analysis, author biography information, character profiles, theme analysis, metaphor analysis, and top ten quotes on classic literature.

This article investigates how the social work literature has been affected by new theories of domestic violence and analyzes the impact that these theories have had on practice with battered women. In the s, wife abuse became a concern of sociologists, feminists, and family theorists.

violence against women and their varied patterns calls for examining and testing some of the important existing theories. The positive and negative features of existing theories can be used to know the causes of violence against women.

Each theory provides a different lens through which we can examine aspect of violent behavior. In an effort to account for the shortcomings of the classical battered women’s theory, Gondolf and Fisher offered the markedly different survivor theory of battered women’s syndrome, which consists of four important elements.

An analysis of different theories on battered women
Rated 0/5 based on 63 review
Battered Women's Syndrome: Origins, Theory, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder - SchoolWorkHelper